Dolly: Anita Brookner

“I reflected how easy it is for a man to reduce women of a certain age to imbecility. All he has to do is give an impersonation of desire, or better still, of secret knowledge, for a woman to feel herself a source of power”

Anita Brookner’s novel Dolly is an introspective, quiet, beautifully written novel, placed squarely in the character-study category. The novel describes the minuscule world of our narrator, Jane, the only child of a very happy loving marriage between her two parents, Henrietta Ferber and Paul Manning. As the only, much loved child brought up in a happy home, the single cloud of discontent to appear on the horizon appears in the form of Jane’s rather exotic Aunt Dolly, who is married to Henrietta’s brother, Hugo. Dolly, at first, appears as a very minor, distant character in Jane’s life, but over the years her importance grows.

Dolly begins when Jane is a child, and one of the significant events in her childhood is the arrival of Aunt Dolly and Uncle Hugo from Brussels. Jane is fascinated by Dolly for her exoticism–her powerful perfume, her foreign mannerisms and her expensive clothing. Dolly, who is childless, isn’t exactly a doting aunt, however, and her entrances and exits into Jane’s childhood, adolescence and young adulthood are punctuated with advice–mainly directed towards getting a man. These snippets of advice that could so easily wither a girl of weaker character serve only to intrigue Jane in their disconnect and frank absurdity. Wise, self-possessed Jane realises that Dolly’s barbed comments reveal more about the speaker than her intended target.


A great deal of the story goes back into the recent Ferber/Manning family history, and we see that Toni Ferber, Jane’s grandmother, who originally hailed from Vienna, is a spoiled, autocratic, selfish woman whose husband eventually gets the sense and courage to run off. Toni Ferber, left to her own affluent devices, dominates the life of her son, Hugo, and mostly ignores her daughter, Henrietta. When Toni Ferber and Hugo meet Dolly and her German mother at a seaside resort, Toni, fatally underestimating Dolly’s character and imagining that she will make a malleable daughter-in-law, pushes her son into Dolly’s arms. For his part, Hugo is content to exchange one domineering woman for another.

On the other side of the family, there’s Jane’s Manning grandmother:

My other grandmother I knew even less, a fact which I did not regret since she seemed, from what I heard of her, to be slightly mad, and may even have been so for all I know. She was a widow living in South Kensington with two small wire-haired terriers to whom she devoted all her leisure hours. She really should have been a dog breeder rather than a mother, for she felt for her son a mild affection only one degree warmer than indifference, whereas she would actually play games with the dogs, for whom she bought expensive rubber toys. The dogs were taken out morning and afternoon for an extensive run in Hyde Park, where my tireless grandmother, dressed winter and summer in trousers, a short-sleeved blouse, and an old tweed jacket belonging to her dead husband, threw balls and sticks, shouted instructions and encouragements, and scarcely noticed the seasons changing all around her. 

Jane’s observant eye records Dolly’s behaviour and mannerisms from her “meaningless smile” to her irritation and constant barbed comments about money. Dolly has a way of diminishing other women, and it’s that power that fascinates Jane. She records the trajectory of Dolly’s life, and quietly, in the background, Jane. alone but not lonely, evolves into an accomplished woman.

Not a great deal happens in the novel, and for its treacly-slow pace, some readers may not enjoy Dolly. Possibly because I once had an exotic aunt of my own, Dolly had great appeal. Anita Brookner creates some powerful characters here–the Manning grandmother, for example, who doesn’t actually appear except as a description. I like the way Brookner divided her characters into quiet people and those who dominate and take control. Jane’s parents are indeed “a haven to each other,” and their relationship, given their respective backgrounds, makes a great deal of sense.

I wasn’t quite sure about the ending which, while it rather nicely focuses on Jane’s career, extrapolates on the idea of Sleeping Beauty, and what women want. The novel covers many decades and slips in the idea of the shifting roles of women. This connects to Dolly and how a woman who has used her looks and her sex to get ahead in life adjusts to aging, but I wasn’t entirely pleased with that last chapter.

I have to send out a thank you to Jacqui for pointing me towards Brookner with her review of Providence. I thought, from reading the review that I’d like the book, but then at the same time I also thought I’d read an Anita Brookner book and disliked it. The title of the book I’d read eluded me (I initially thought it was Hotel du Lac), and then after some digging I realised I’d read a book by Anita Shreve NOT Anita Brookner and in all fairness to the latter, I had to read one.



Filed under Brookner Anita, Fiction

18 responses to “Dolly: Anita Brookner

  1. She’s one of those authors I keep on collecting but haven’t read yet. I had a mother who was a bit of an American not Dolly, so thus appeals to me but I have to read her other novels first. Btw, I too read an Anita Shreve and was underwhelmed.

  2. What did that auto fill do! A bit of an aunt Dolly not American not Dolly. This iPad keeps on tricking me into writing utter nonsense.

  3. Oh no. When it’s not auto-correct or auto-fill it is my bad typing.

  4. I have to get to Hotel du lac one of these days.

  5. I’m just writing a post on Look At Me, which I loved.That power women have to “diminish” other women is a theme there too. She is such a clever, perceptive writer, and so subtle.

  6. I loved Hotel du Lac. Just loved it.
    From your description of the book, that cover is just brilliant.

  7. Thanks for the mention, Guy – much appreciated. I’m so glad you enjoyed it. There are some mildly exotic European relatives in Providence as well, so maybe this is a theme that runs through some of her work. The characterisation sounds excellent here – unusual and distinctive. I’ll have to add it the list.

    • I hope you like it, Jacqui. I also have Providence here bought after your review.

      • It might be a while before I get to it as I already have a couple of unread Brookners on the shelves. It’s definitely in my list though, that’s for sure. I’ll be interested to see how you get on with Providence. Looking back on it from a distance, I’m not entirely comfortable with the ending as it seems a little too dramatic and slightly out-of-kilter with the rest of the book – at least that’s how I see it in my mind now.

  8. I have read quite a few Anita Brookners, but not since blogging: Look at me, Family and friends, Hotel du Lac, A family romance, and perhaps others (e.g. Providence rings a bell, as does A friend from England). I’m pretty sure that A family romance is Dolly by another name. I read it in 1995. Ah, I’ve just checked Wikipedia and it is.

    Anyhow, what you say about this book i.e. “Not a great deal happens in the novel, and for its treacly-slow pace” is true, really, of all of her books I’d say. And there can be a certain sameness about her stories, that is many are about often lonely, isolated woman, but her writing is exquisite.

    You know, I presume, that Brookner is (was) an art historian by profession?

    I would love to read another of hers just to have her on my blog!! Is that silly?

  9. I’m working on a review of Undue Influence and it’s another isolated woman–although this one has some frayed edges.

    No I understand completely why you’d want to add her to your blog. It’s like having a hand of playing cards and you want a full house. Or something.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.