Elizabeth Finch, from Julian Barnes examines the relationship between the narrator, Neil, and his one-time professor. The novel explores the problems of memory and biography and asks how well can we ever know a person–especially a multi-faceted, private person such as Elizabeth Finch.
Elizabeth Finch teaches an adult education course, “Culture and Civilisation.” The students range in age from 20-40, and there’s a great deal of speculation about Elizabeth, a curious woman of contrasts, and her private life. Neil notes that it easy “to stray into fantasy.” As a lecturer/professor, Elizabeth Finch, or EF as Neil later refers to her, is challenging, yet she provides a reading list which is “optional” and notes “I may well not be the best teacher, in the sense of the one most suited to your temperament and cast of mind.” That last sentence, which seems so casually spoken on the first day, turns out to have great significance.
She appeared to have settled on her look some time ago. It could still be called stylish: another decade, and it might be antique or, perhaps vintage. In summer, a box-pleated skirt, usually navy; tweed in winter. Sometimes she adopted a tartan or kiltish look with a big safety pin (no doubt there’s a special Scottish word for it). Obvious money was spent on blouses, in silk or fine cotton, often striped, and in no way translucent. Occasionally a brooch, always small and, as they say, discreet, yet somehow refulgent. She rarely wore earrings (were her lobes even pierced? now there’s a question). On her left little finger, a silver ring which we took to be inherited, rather than bought or given. Her hair was a kind of sandy grey, shapely and of unvarying length. I imagined a regular fortnightly appointment. Well, she believed in artifice, as she told us more than once. And artifice, as she also observed, was not incompatible with truth.
The novel can be sliced into 3 sections: the introduction (and departure) of Elizabeth Finch, the middle section which is Neil’s long-delayed student essay on Julian the Apostate, and the final section which covers the end of Elizabeth’s career and Neil’s conclusions about his former professor.
I loved the first part of the book as Neil charts his relationship with Elizabeth Finch. Sometimes it’s the hard to define relationships that are the most interesting. EF rather uncannily reminded me of a professor who later became a friend for several decades, and so when I read that Neil intended to become EF’s biographer, I was fascinated. Unfortunately, when Neil delivers his student essay as some sort of post-death tribute to Elizabeth Finch, this entire middle section threw me in the Slough of Despond. I probably wouldn’t have minded reading about Julian the Apostate if I’d sought a book on the subject, but as is, the plot seems hijacked…no … abandoned. In the final section, Neil returns to the subject of EF and the novel revives as he discovers that he was not the only student who maintained a relationship with this very private, exacting person. Meanwhile, Neil tries to excavate details of EF’s private life and finally talks to a former student who has an entirely different opinion of the professor. Ultimately, we are left with more questions than answers, and the mystery of a professor who became one of the most significant people in Neil’s life, while another student remembers her as rather ordinary. What does that say about our perceptions, our biases, our memories?
7 responses to “Elizabeth Finch: Julian Barnes”
I had the same reaction to Julian the Apostate, in fact I only skimmed the last section of the book because he’d lost me there. I wonder if your having had a similar professor influenced your judgment of EF, because I didn’t find her to be of great interest at any stage. It left me feeling a bit puzzled about what he was trying to achieve….
He? The author or Neil? Yes I am sure knowing my own Elizabeth FInch caused me to be very interested. Honestly, the connections, the details…it was uncanny.
Barnes. I wondered if he had Elizabeth Costello in mind. It would be quite a Barnesian thing to do, as well as having “St Julian”
I wasn’t so thrilled by part 2 either, but I liked the book as a whole and I thought part 3 brought it all together. (anzlitlovers.com/2022/06/20/elizabeth-finch-by-julian-barnes/)
IMO, which is free, from a less accomplished writer, the novel would be knocked sideways, but since it’s Barnes, several reviews (professional) expressed the view that the author had various intentions with this structure. I have no idea.
Thanks, Lisa. Will take a look.
Other Gert has reminded me of the possibility that Barnes had Anital Brookner in mind. Here’s a bit from a Sydney Morning Herald rv:
Elizabeth Finch “is about the most un-self-pitying person I have ever met. She knew the world to be unfair, and thought it naive of anyone else not to see that. She was, in her deepest self, a stoic.” This is not a line from Julian Barnes’ novel Elizabeth Finch, but from an obituary he wrote about his friend, the art historian and novelist Anita Brookner. She died in 2016. But it is a precise description of the fictional Finch from the eponymous novel.
I won’t post the link because it will send me to spam, but look it up if you like under the title:
“Too much irony? Julian Barnes’ style evokes an exasperated sigh”
Thanks Gerts. Not my fav. Barnes at any rate.