The Watch Tower by Elizabeth Harrower

The Watch Tower, from Australian novelist Elizabeth Harrower is set in the years surrounding WWII. The story begins when sisters Laura and Clare are withdrawn from private boarding school by their self-focused mother, a British woman who’s never really adjusted to life in Australia. Stella Vaizey’s lack of adjustment probably isn’t made easier by the fact that she feels a bit let down by her husband. Dr. Vaizey died unexpectedly, and his death which seems the final proof  that he was “unreliable” has left his widow and two daughters in financial hardship. Both Laura and Clare must give up their ambitions for university, and after their large home is sold, they move to Manly, a suburb of Sydney. Here’s Stella Vaizey:

“I want you and Clare to take over from tomorrow morning, Miss Muffet.” Stella Vaizey lay back in bed and extended one small, beringed and manicured hand in a final relinquishing gesture. Propped against two pillows, smoking an Abdulla cigarette, she looked tolerantly at Clare, who sat on the dressing-table stool, leaning on her knees, plaits hanging, one navy-blue ribbon untied; and at Laura, who stood, back to the windows, assessing the strange bedroom and its furnishings with quick little glances. Laura hated that ‘Miss Muffet.’ It wasn’t well intended.

“You’re fixed up at your business college; Clare’s enrolled at her school, and they’re both within walking distance. You know where the shops are, and the beach is at the bottom of the hill, so you’ve got nothing to complain about, have you?”

She was crossing them off her list!

“And now that everything’s settled, I’m going to expect you both to take some responsibility. I’m very tired. I’ve had a busy, upsetting time with that oaf of a solicitor bungling everything and selling the house. It’s been a great-” her eyes filled with tears. She sneezed, and sneezed again, and groaned luxuriously as if to say, ‘There! You can see for yourselves how ill-treated I’ve been.’

Laura finishes business school and then gets a job at a company owned by industrious bachelor Felix Shaw. With WWII gathering momentum, Stella Vaizey longs to return to her old crowd in England, and it seems nothing less than fortuitous when Felix proposes to Laura. He even buys a large, impressive house and agrees to take in Clare too. This is the liberation Stella has been waiting for, and gently, subtly, Laura is eased into marriage.

But Felix Shaw isn’t quite what he seems, and as his business interests fluctuate, both Laura and Clare pay the penalties for his erratic decisions. Gradually Felix’s dark side emerges….

The Felix Shaws of this world have an innate ability to identify and capture the vulnerable women who have the misfortune to enter their sphere of acquaintance. At first The Watch Tower seems to be Laura’s story, but as the plot develops, the story is Clare’s. Clare has the choice of remaining with Laura as a powerless witness of a hellish marriage or she can break free and abandon her sister.

The Watch Tower does an excellent job of creating its three main characters and gradually building the details of the domestic tyranny endured by Laura and Clare. Domestic abusers and marital tyrants are skilled at creating false worlds and then imprisoning their victims within those invisible walls. So true to form, Felix remains well-respected by others while at home he’s a monster. There are hints of Felix’s repressed homosexuality, and certainly he values his relationships with other males while his relationship with Laura and Clare is infused with hatred and loathing. Often Felix appears to bait Laura and Clare:

“Months ago they had learned that there was no defence but silence, and that was no defence. He did so enjoy cajoling them into speech, but he had been known to be provoked to the very edge of violence by the sound of an answering voice. Not that he minded being brought to the edge of violence.”

 All these details are well-developed and believable, and Felix’s gradual transformation occurs as he isolates the sisters first from the world and then from each other.

On a personal level, I find it difficult to read novels in which characters are acted upon–endlessly. I wanted someone to do something in this novel, so I became frustrated with the female characters as they continued to soak up Felix’s behaviour and escaling violence. That criticism voiced, I realise that that is the whole point of the story. These women take it because a) they have few other choices and b) it becomes ‘normal.’

In spite of the novel’s painful subject matter–the destruction of one human being by another, the plot does not wallow in emotion, and much of the drama remains delicately understated. There’s not a great deal of introspection here as people carry on and pretend everything is perfectly normal even when it’s quite clear that it’s not.  For its exploration of the relationship between sisters, the sacrifices of 1940s women who are forced by circumstance to drop dreams of education for the terrors of becoming one man’s cooks, cleaners, and general factotums, then this could be a classic feminist text along with titles such as Mrs. Caliban (Rachel Ingalls) and Housekeeping (Marilynne Robinson).

The brief bio notes at the front of the book state that Harrower was born in 1928 in Sydney, lived in London in the 50s, and then returned to Australia. The Watch Tower was published in 1966. It’s a somewhat unfortunate title as a search yields a lot of religious material.


Filed under Harrower Elizabeth

12 responses to “The Watch Tower by Elizabeth Harrower

  1. Oh dear, LOL re your last line! She probably didn’t know it at the time – I guess The Watch Tower was around then but she wouldn’t have realised the future implications of choosing that title.

    I have heard of Harrower but haven’t read her. How did she comes across your path? You have certainly intrigued me anyhow as the subject matter – women’s experience and world war 2 – is very appealing to me.

  2. This was sitting on my shelf for years. I can’t remember where I got the recommendation to read it.

    Some websites refer to the book as The Watchtower, but my copy shows the title as three words (which adds to the unfortunate confusion).

    Is Harrower still read in Australia?

    • Why didn’t I answer this at the time? Anyhow, no she’s not but maybe the new release will change that.

      Love your review … Thanks for reminding me you’d read it. She does a wonderful job, as you say, of showing the insidious way it becomes “normal” particularly for Laura. And the language is absolutely delicious. I also like the way she builds up tension and sustains it in a way that we, probably like the sisters, never know when the next blow up will care.

      • Are you going to read any of her others?

        • Sorry Guy I was travelling when I wrote the review and so didn’t keep up with all the related discussion. I think Text is going to publish The Long Prospect later in the year so I might try to read that, though DKS commenting on my review of The watch tower isn’t very complimentary of it.

  3. Writing about domestic abuse must I think be peculiarly challenging. The issue is that people accept as normal that which is fundamentally wrong, that they adapt through fear, habit and lack of choice to that they’d never knowingly agree to up front.

    That’s difficult stuff. The fact it’s essentially pulled off here puts this potentially on my TBR pile.

  4. I liked the way this novel didn’t tread into thriller territory. That made it less exciting (it’s not exciting at all), but it made the erosion of Laura’s personality and will power that more horrifying.

    Have you seen Criminal Justice II?

  5. Max: If it’s difficult to find a copy of The watch Tower, I’d be happy to send you mine.

  6. That’s very kind Guy, do you not think you’ll read it again?

  7. No, it’s in my give-away stack.

  8. Cool, drop me an email and I’ll send you my address.



  9. FrancisRonald Harrower

    Elizabeth Harrower is still alive

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.